The Dialectics of Islamic Law and National Law in Protecting Children's Rights

Abstract views: 4 / PDF downloads: 2

Authors

  • Lutfi Firdausi UIN Sayyid Ali Rahmatullah Tulungagung

Keywords:

Islamic Law, National Law, Child Rights Protection, Law Harmonization, Substantive Justice

Abstract

The protection of children's rights in Indonesia's legal system faces the challenge of harmonizing Islamic law norms with national law, especially in regulating child marriage, custody rights (hadhanah), and children's civil relationships. This study aims to analyze the construction of children's rights protection from the perspective of Islamic law and national law, identify dialectics and potential normative tensions, and formulate a legal harmonization model oriented toward substantive justice. This study uses a normative legal research method with library research through statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. Primary legal materials include the Qur'an, hadith, legislation, the Compilation of Islamic Law, and Constitutional Court decisions, while secondary legal materials cover fiqh literature, legal theory, and previous research. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively using content analysis through systematic and teleological interpretation. The research results show that Islamic law and national law share the same orientation in ensuring child protection but show differences in normative construction regarding the minimum marriage age, custody priorities, and the civil status of children. This study produces a conceptual model of law harmonization through three stages: identifying relationships between norms, evaluating protection objectives, and constructing fair interpretations. The integration of the principles of maqashid sharia, the best interests of the child, and substantive justice becomes the main foundation in bringing the two legal systems together. This study concludes that legal harmonization should go beyond just formally aligning norms by putting the fulfillment of children's rights and welfare as the main focus in developing Islamic family law and national law in Indonesia.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-01

How to Cite

Lutfi Firdausi. (2026). The Dialectics of Islamic Law and National Law in Protecting Children’s Rights. SAMARA INSANI: Indonesian Journal of Islamic Law and Family Studies, 1(2), 118–135. Retrieved from https://journal.agrapanamedia.org/index.php/samara-insani/article/view/282